Faith-Based Nonprofit Recruitment
Recruiting for faith-based nonprofits goes beyond filling roles — it’s about finding candidates who align with God’s purpose for your organization. Standard job postings can’t convey the depth of this calling.
Our approach is different. We highlight what makes your organization unique, attracting passive talent who is committed to propelling your mission forward, whether active faith is a prerequisite or not.
Even under tight budget constraints, we give strategic advice on where to be flexible, ensuring we find the ideal candidate ready to carry your torch into the future.
We identify and connect organizations with passive talent for these positions and more:
- Chief Development Officer
- Chief Executive Officer/Executive Director
- Chief Financial Officer
- Chief Information Officer
- Chief Operating Officer
- Chief People Officer
- Chief Programs Officer
- Controller
- Director of Corporate Alliances
- Director of Development
- Chief Development Officer
- Chief Executive Officer/Executive Director
- Chief Financial Officer
- Chief Information Officer
- Chief Operating Officer
- Chief People Officer
- Chief Programs Officer
- Controller
- Director of Corporate Alliances
- Director of Development
- Director of Finance & Administration
- Director of Human Resources/People Operations
- Director of Information Technology
- Director of Planned Giving
- Major Gift Officer
- Medical Director
- Regional Director
- Senior Finance & Accounting Associate
- Vice President – All Operational Areas
- Director of Finance & Administration
- Director of Human Resources/People Operations
- Director of Information Technology
- Director of Planned Giving
- Major Gift Officer
- Medical Director
- Regional Director
- Senior Finance & Accounting Associate
- Vice President – All Operational Areas
Faith’s Footprint in Nonprofit Employment

Religious organizations and other subsectors make up 98% of nonprofit employment.

1,473,716 people employed by religious organizations in the U.S. as of 2023.

Religious organizations in the U.S. now employ more workers on average than five years ago.
Strengthening Missions with Thoughtful Recruitment
- Flexible Pricing Model: Attuned to the budgetary realities of faith-based organizations, Duffy Group offers a cost-efficient model, charging only for actual hours worked.
- Specialization in Hard-to-Fill Positions: We thrive on finding talent that is both highly skilled and shares your same values, thanks to our thorough research and vetting.
- Telling Your Story: We share your unique mission with candidates in a way that resonates, drawing in people who are not just talented, but truly excited to be part of your journey.
- Guidance on Flexibility: We offer expert advice on where to show flexibility in your recruitment strategy to attract top talent while staying within budget.
- Denominational Nuances: Our recruiters recognize when denominational alignment is crucial, ensuring searches are tailored to fit specific faith requirements and preferences.
Clients Include
- Beacon of Hope
- Brophy College Preparatory
- Catholic Charities Community Services Arizona
- Catholic Charities Diocese of Arlington
- Catholic Charities Diocese of Charlotte
- Catholic Charities of Corpus Christi
- Catholic Charities of Rochester
- Catholic Charities San Bernardino and Riverside
- Catholic Community Foundation
- Beacon of Hope
- Brophy College Preparatory
- Catholic Charities Community Services Arizona
- Catholic Charities Diocese of Arlington
- Catholic Charities Diocese of Charlotte
- Catholic Charities of Corpus Christi
- Catholic Charities of Rochester
- Catholic Charities San Bernardino and Riverside
- Catholic Community Foundation
- Catholic Charities of Southern Nevada
- Catholic Community Services of Southern Arizona
- Catholic Education Arizona
- Circle the City
- Commonwealth Catholic Charities
- Diocese of Phoenix
- Franciscan Renewal Center
- Habitat for Humanity Central Arizona
- Kino Border Initiative
- Mission of Mercy
- Newman Center, NAU
- Phoenix Rescue Mission
- Rescue Mission Alliance
- St. Barnabas Episcopal Church
- St. Francis Xavier Church
- St. Joseph the Worker
- St. Mary’s Food Bank Alliance
- Catholic Charities of Southern Nevada
- Catholic Community Services of Southern Arizona
- Catholic Education Arizona
- Circle the City
- Commonwealth Catholic Charities
- Diocese of Phoenix
- Franciscan Renewal Center
- Habitat for Humanity Central Arizona
- Kino Border Initiative
- Mission of Mercy
- Newman Center, NAU
- Phoenix Rescue Mission
- Rescue Mission Alliance
- St. Barnabas Episcopal Church
- St. Francis Xavier Church
- St. Joseph the Worker
- St. Mary’s Food Bank Alliance
The Informed Way with Duffy Recruitment Research™
Unlike contingent search’s quantity over quality approach, and retained search’s costlier upfront fees, Duffy Recruitment Research™ is a customized, research-driven recruitment strategy that delivers a short list of interested qualified candidates and market data for smarter hiring strategies. It’s insightful, cost-effective and future proof. Ready to make the informed choice in hiring?